Dec. 9, 2011
There's something interesting going on here. The Washington Post is reporting the top show for conservatives is the long running home improvement franchise, This Old House. Meanwhile, the tops for liberals is the irreverently humorous and oh so snarky, "The Daily Show" (The analysis does not include news, sports or music programming).
Now I don't lean Jon Stewart's way politically, but I've seen enough of his show to catch the appeal. If you like shooting fish in a barrel, and you already believe conservatives are those unfortunate fish, then Jon's your guy. He's in the tear-down business, and supplies a lot of Americans (young people in particular) with what passes for news. Not surprisingly, I'm not one of them.
On the other hand, after Saturday cartoons wrap up, my boys and I will often watch This Old House. Or as they like to call it, "The Man Show." I'll never forget the day we were watching the program and my oldest son asked me, "Dad, who are the bad guys?" He's four, so I didn't tell him, "Jon Stewart." Only kidding, Jon.
As anecdotal as media choices may be, the contrast between these two shows is stark indeed. It reminds me of Proverbs 14:1: The wise woman builds her house, but with her own hands the foolish one tears hers down.
I think it says something that out of all the programming choices available, conservatives favor a family-centric, home building show hosted by a genial group of working class dudes. It's reflective of our values: we're builders of families, homes and businesses. We'd much rather focus on our own hearths than those on K street, Wall street or Pennsylvania Avenue. We're not looking for a fight except when one lands on our doorstep, and we're really not that into politics. We tend to believe the family is the primary vehicle through which good culture is communicated, and have much lower expectations when it comes to government. Please don't ask me to explain "The Bachelor." Aside from its obvious nod to sexuality, there is no explanation for such a show.
It's interesting, too, that of all the programming choices available, our liberal neighbors favor a biting political comedy-entary. (I don't think that's a word yet, but it probably should be.) What values is this reflecting? Perhaps: government is the center of public life and the highest of man's achievements, or maybe, it's good fun to tear down those who disagree. That's all conjecture, of course, as I don't really watch the Daily Show. I can think of plenty of counterexamples in my own life to these extrapolations, but itd be hard to argue that the growth of leviathan doesnt undermine the family. One neednt look further than family formation and fertility rates in Western Europe to see how this plays out.
In any case, I've got to go fix some electrical issues at our new old house. I'll see if my boys want to help.