Two American Idols, One Celebration of Christmas
by Rosalind Bergen
December 15, 2009
The Carrie Underwood Christmas Special aired last week. I was looking forward to it. I put on my fuzzy slippers, dropped a couple of extra marshmallows into my hot cocoa, and snuggled up in front of the TV. I couldn’t wait to hear her sing my favorite Christmas song, “O Holy Night”. I reached for the Kleenex box. One must be prepared for tears, especially when she hits that ever-famous note toward the end: “Diviiiiiiiiiine.” I was like a kid at Christmas, bursting with anticipation.
So, you can imagine my shock, sitting there on the floor in my living room, staring at the TV, mouth agape, at the opening of the Carrie Underwood Christmas Special: Miss Underwood rises from under the stage in a throne-like chair, smoke swirling and lights flashing. She’s clad in skin-tight, black leather from head to toe. I didn’t know hair spray could get hair that high? I didn’t know Christmas was about Carrie Underwood. Male dancers (wearing only pants – yikes – and matching, black leather, of course) flanked her on all sides. They all started dancing… err, more like flailing, all over the stage. The song she sang (though, is it technically a “song” if it lacks a discernable melody?) was no more a Christmas song than fruitcake is cake.
I grabbed the remote and hit “OFF”. Sigh. “Speaking of fruitcake…” I trot off to the kitchen. I figure I’ll have better luck getting into the Christmas spirit with a slice of grandma’s fruitcake. And that’s not sayin’ much. Sorry, Grandma.
But, Christmas is about rejuvenation and re-birth, and last night, I got my second chance. I was on the treadmill at the gym, of all places, barely eeking out that first mile. (One too many marshmallows, apparently). There were about eight TVs on the wall, each broadcasting a different channel. “Let’s see, what can I watch to help me reach mile two?” TV one: news. Pass. TV two: news. Pass. TV three: …what’s this? I see a church sanctuary, brightly lit with candles and adorned with wreaths and garland. A gospel choir is swaying back and forth. I see Jennifer Hudson belting something out at a microphone. Could it be? I scrambled for my headset so I could listen. They’re singing, “Silent Night!”
Alleluia! Throughout the next forty-five minutes, I was delighted by one traditional, Christmas carol after the next. No self-glorification or self-aggrandizement. No dance choreography. Not even any Rudolf. Only the beautiful singing of the old, great Christmas carols and hymns. Only the celebration of love, giving and family. At one point, during an interview before a song, Jennifer Hudson tells us, “Jesus is the light of the world.” Now this is a Christmas Special. I was invigorated. I looked down at my treadmill’s screen. Five miles?! I haven’t run five miles in at least five years! (Okay, a decade, at least).
Thank you, Jennifer Hudson, for producing an appropriate, traditional Christmas special. In an age where Christmas decorations are stripped from public buildings, and citizens are forced to take down nativity scenes displayed in their yards, I know I speak for many when I say, I appreciate you remembering Christ in Christmas. And thank you ABC (did I actually say that?) for your bravery in broadcasting Hudson’s show. And P.S., Miss Hudson, the note you struck in “Diiiiiiiiiivine”, was far more beautiful than Carrie Underwood’s ever could have been.
Family Research Council is a 501c(3) non-profit organization. If this post has been helpful to you, please consider a gift to help us continue to advance Faith, Family, and Freedom.
Comments
“In a recent interview, I was asked how I reconciled being a Christian with performing at events for my gay fans. I find it upsetting that some folks equate being a Christian with being intolerant of gay people. That may, unfortunately, be true for some, but it is not true for me. I have talked often of my love and support of the gay community. I have said again and again that it was the gay community that supported me long before and long after American Idol, and kept me working and motivated. It is the gay community that celebrated my voice and my size and my personality long before Dreamgirls. Yes, I was raised Baptist. Yes, I was taught that the Bible has certain views on homosexuality. The Bible also teaches us not to judge. It teaches us to love one another as God loves us all. I love my sister, my two best friends and my director dearly. They happen to be gay. So what? While some search for controversy, I hope that my friends and fans who know me, know where I stand.”
-J Hud
I totally agree with your assessment of Ms. Hudson’s special. I was very disappointed when the credits started rolling, I could have watched her for another hour or two. My hope is this special will become a DVD/CD available for purchase. Merry Christmas and Happy New Year.
for the 100000000th thime, Carries special was a Holiday special, not a Christmas special. Jennifer Hudsons was a Christmas special. Carrie’s was more like a variety show! and you should watch it again because Carrie did amazing on Oh Holy Night, I think you would have loved it!
Nice…I’m glad ABC is representing a bit, and I’m glad it was so engaging that you ran 5 miles. Speaking of stripping Christ from Christmas; recent news from a school in CT (Eric Brown is the principal): the official celebration will be “Happy Winter.” Not Merry Christmas or even Happy Holidays. Society has become so politically correct that now, at a risk of offending just about EVERYONE, we’re called to regale the holiday as “Happy Winter.” Who celebrates Winter, anyway? I mean–most people can’t wait for Winter to be over! Pretty soon it’ll be “Merry Wintmas.” I don’t understand the reasoning here–if you take religion out of the holiday, it ceases to be a holiday. That’s all I have. Keep writing.
Once again Carrie’s was not a Christmas Special!!!! Her vocals are amazing and the show was very entertaining, which was the purpose!
Here’s a suggestion for enjoying the Christmas season: turn off the television and sign carols yourself (better yet, band together with friends and go door-to-door), volunteer at a soup kitchen, gather the kids together to wrap up some of the underloved toys to take to children who otherwise want receive any gifts.
The emphais by FRC in televion programs and retail shopping in the Christmas is quite revealing.

By: G-A-Y | December 15, 2009 at 1:46 pm
And Jennifer Hudson has been a far more outspoken advocate for the LGBT community. So thank you, FRC, for supporting her so fully!!
Though I do like Carrie too